395 Shanley St | Cheektowaga, NY
At Papa J’s Pizza, great food and great company are what we’re all about. What started as a small family pizza shop has grown into a local favorite where everyone feels at home. We take pride in serving classic, handcrafted pizzas, hearty comfort dishes, and all the bar favorites you crave — all made with fresh ingredients and a whole lot of love.
Pizza, wings, and fish fry
Three things Cheektowaga keeps coming back for. Generous portions, real food, no fuss.
Open when everyone else closes
Late-night pickup, fried dough, cheesecake bites — still going when you need it most.
Your favorites, just a few clicks away
Order online from Papa J’s Pizza Bar & Grill and enjoy your favorite pizza and wings without waiting in line. Choose what you want, place your order with ease, and get your meal ready for pickup or delivery. Make your next meal simple by ordering from Papa J’s online today.
From the kitchen
The patio on a good day
Warm weather, good company, nowhere to be. Guests say they lose track of time out here.
Make Your Next Gathering Easy
Bring Papa J’s Pizza Bar & Grill to your next party, meeting, or special event with pizza and wings made for sharing. Our catering options make it easy to serve a group without the extra work of planning every dish yourself. Contact Papa J’s to plan your order and make your next gathering a little more convenient.
Save your spot at Papa J’s
Planning a meal at Papa J’s Pizza Bar & Grill? Make a reservation ahead of time and enjoy a relaxed visit with your group. Choose your preferred time, gather your guests, and let us get ready to welcome you.
Visit Us Today
Address: 395 Shanley St, Cheektowaga, NY 14206, United States
Phone: +1 716-894-0594
Hours:
Monday 4 pm–3 am
Tuesday 4 pm–3 am
Wednesday 4 pm–3 am
Thursday 4 pm–3 am
Friday 11 am–4 am
Saturday 11 am–4 am
Sunday 11 am–3 am
Very friendly staff , great food Honey cajun wings perfect how I like them will be back fast and open late
I am definitely going back. Anybody that remember Scotties on delavan ave back in the day, GO TO PAPA J'S. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Food was very good nice and hot 10 outta 10 definitely recommend 👌🏾 👍🏾 😋
Papa J's Pizza Bar & Grill Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for White Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Cheeseburger, Jalapeno Poppers, Cheesecake, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers, Onion Rings, Fish Tacos, Taco Pizza, Taco Salad, Tater Tots, Fried Chicken, Antipasto Salad, Chicken Tacos, Sandwiches, Fries, Cheese Pizza, Dessert, Veggie Pizza, Salads, Wings, Burgers, Blt, Deli Sandwiches, Chicken Wings, Chicken Restaurant, Garlic Bread, Fish Sandwich, Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, and Meat Lovers Pizza
